Region choice moves a player’s ping by 30-60 ms, which is more than most game servers can earn back with any amount of hardware tuning. The mistake teams make is picking a region by provider reputation rather than by where the population actually sits. The method below builds that answer from radius bands and a population-weighted average instead of a guess.
Three numbers drive everything: fibre round-trip latency per 100 km of route, the p95 latency your game’s netcode tolerates, and the share of your monthly active players inside each radius band. Get those three and the region falls out of the arithmetic.
The Latency Bands That Actually Matter
Light in fibre covers roughly 200 km per millisecond one way, so a 1,000 km route costs about 10 ms round trip plus 1-3 ms per peering hop. Measured fibre round-trip latency in North America tracks near 1.0-1.2 ms per 100 km of route distance, with metro access and switching adding 2-8 ms. Rough expectations by distance: under 500 km, 5-12 ms; 500-1,200 km, 10-20 ms; 1,200-2,500 km, 20-40 ms; 2,500-4,000 km, 40-65 ms.
Then map the game onto those bands. Fast arena shooters at 128 tick want p95 under 40 ms for a good experience, tolerable to about 60 ms. Tactical shooters at 64 tick tolerate 70 ms. Survival and MMO-style games with client-side prediction are comfortable to 100 ms and playable to 140 ms, because most interaction is not frame-exact. Anything over 150 ms is felt in every input regardless of genre. Those ceilings, not the datacenter’s marketing, are what define your acceptable radius.
Population Is Not Evenly Distributed
The US population centroid sits near Lebanon, Missouri, but the gaming-population centroid sits further east and denser. Roughly 45% of the US lives in the Eastern time zone, 29% Central, 17% Pacific, and 6% Mountain, with the rest in Alaska and Hawaii. Canada shifts the picture north but adds only about 12% to the pool in most community servers. If your Discord and Steam data shows 55% Eastern, 25% Central, 15% Pacific and 5% Mountain, the population-weighted centroid is well inside the Eastern-Central border corridor.
Do this with real numbers rather than national averages. Pull the last 90 days of connection logs, geolocate each player’s IP to a metro, and bucket into 250 km rings around each candidate city. The bucket counts decide the tie-break between two cities that are both within budget for most players. A server in the right city for your top three metros usually beats a server in a nominally “central” location that adds 15 ms to 70% of your players.
Candidate Regions and What Each One Buys
Ashburn, Virginia is the densest peering point in North America. It is the best single location if more than half your players are on the East Coast, and it reaches Chicago in roughly 14-18 ms, Atlanta in 12-16 ms, Toronto in 14-20 ms. Its weakness is the Pacific: Los Angeles is 55-65 ms away, which pushes West Coast arena players past the comfortable band.
Chicago is the balanced choice for mixed US communities. It reaches New York in 18-24 ms, Los Angeles in 42-50 ms, Dallas in 22-28 ms and Atlanta in 16-22 ms. No region of the lower 48 is worse than about 65 ms. For a national spread with no dominant metro, Chicago minimises the weighted average more often than any other single city. Dallas works best for a South-heavy population, reaches Los Angeles in about 30-38 ms, and is closest to Latin American players. Los Angeles or Seattle only makes sense if Pacific and Mountain players dominate, or for an Asia-Pacific audience that accepts 140-180 ms for EU players. Atlanta competes with Ashburn for the southeast and adds a short hop to Florida.
Test With Traceroute, Not Marketing Pages
Every provider publishes a test IP. Run mtr -rwzc 100 <test-ip> from a handful of home connections and from a cloud instance in each target metro, and look at the per-hop loss column, not just the average. A 45 ms average with 0% loss on every hop is better than a 38 ms average with a hop showing 0.8% loss, because packet loss above 0.5% on any hop is felt as rubber-banding even when the ping number is lower.
Also check the peering path, not just the distance. A route that transits a congested IXP at peak hours will show p95 latency 20-30 ms above its p50. Compare mtr output at 03:00 and 20:00 on a weekday. If the p95 spread widens past 15 ms between those windows, transit is unstable for your use case. Request test IPs in each candidate facility and confirm the uplink commit against the bandwidth tiers each dedicated plan includes before you sign a term.
Two Regions Beat One When the Spread Is Wide
If you cannot get p95 under 60 ms for 90% of players from a single city, split the population. One server in Ashburn and one in Los Angeles covers both coasts at 12-25 ms locally and 55-65 ms cross-country, which is worse than a Chicago midpoint for the middle but better for the extremes. Run them as separate instances with a shared login backend, or use a matchmaker that assigns players to the lower-latency instance at connect time.
The cost is roughly double the hardware bill but it removes the 20% of players who would otherwise always play at 70-90 ms. For a 400-player community that is 80 people, and 80 unhappy players cost more in churn than a second mid-range box. Our US dedicated server locations across multiple metro regions can be used this way, with each instance sized independently.
Check the Building, Not Just the City
Two datacenters in the same metro can differ by 4-6 ms depending on where the carrier hotel sits relative to each facility. Ask which carrier hotels the provider peers at and whether it holds direct private interconnects to the major eyeball networks. A facility with direct ports to large consumer ISPs shows 3-8 ms lower p95 on residential connections than one buying transit two hops upstream.
Region Selection Checklist
Pull 90 days of player IPs and bucket them into 250 km rings around Ashburn, Chicago, Dallas and Los Angeles. Pick the p95 ceiling from the game’s netcode, not from a general “low latency” claim. Estimate weighted p95 per candidate city using distance plus 3 ms per peering hop, then validate the top two with mtr at peak and off-peak. If the winner leaves more than 10% of players above the ceiling, plan for two regions rather than one compromise.




Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.